Site Navigation

Home
About
Services
Testimonials
Contact
News
FAQ

Gary's Coins & Stamps

"we accept single items & Collections"

About Us

For more than 45 years, Gary’s Coins & Stamps has been a cornerstone for collectors, historians, and treasure-seekers alike. Founded in 1979, our shop has grown from a small local storefront into a respected destination for collectible coins, currency, stamps, antiques, and other rare and historic items.

With decades of hands-on expertise and a genuine passion for preservation, we provide expert appraisals, fair and transparent buying and selling services, and a thoughtfully curated in-store selection. Every piece we handle carries a story, and our knowledgeable team is dedicated to helping you uncover the history behind each item.

Whether you’re an experienced collector or just beginning your journey, Gary’s Coins & Stamps is here to guide you, answer your questions, and help you build a collection that reflects your interests and curiosity. At Gary’s, we believe every item has a past — and we’re here to help you discover the one that speaks to you.

Areas Served

Our Professional Associations

American Numismatic Association (ANA)

Our Certifications

Professional Coin Grading Service Dealer

What We Offer

Our Specialties include:

Gary's Coins & Stamps is your trusted destination for rare and collectible treasures, specializing in collectible coins, currency, stamps, antiques, and other rare items. With a deep appreciation for history and value, Gary’s offers a curated selection for collectors and enthusiasts alike. Whether you're seeking a unique addition to your collection or looking to appraise and sell a prized item, Gary’s provides expert guidance and personalized service to help you discover and preserve timeless pieces.

Our Services include:

Retail Services: Explore our Collector Shop and enjoy a personalized In-Store Shopping experience where enthusiasts and collectors can browse unique items, rare finds, and curated collections. Whether you're hunting for a specific piece or just browsing, our shop offers a welcoming environment for discovery and connection.
Evaluation Services: Our Appraisal services provide expert evaluations of collectibles, antiques, and other valuable items. With detailed assessments based on market trends and item condition, we help you understand the true worth of your possessions—whether for insurance, resale, or personal knowledge.
We make it easy to Buy and Sell with confidence. Whether you're looking to expand your collection or find a new home for cherished items, our transparent and professional transaction services ensure fair pricing, secure exchanges, and a smooth experience from start to finish.

Our Products include:

Coins
Collectible Items
Unique Items
Gold Coins
Collectible Currency
Jewelry

Testimonials

On 8/18/2025 Ryan had this to say:
I’ve been a customer for almost two years now and there’s a reason that I continue coming back. Chris and the gang have provided excellent customer service and I have learned so much from them. They are always kind and patient with me and my family. Now, I think of them as good friends. I cannot recommend Gary’s enough. Testimonial written by Ryan on this site.

On 7/19/2025 Jonathan Derrie had this to say:
My one stop shop for coins.

On 4/30/2025 Carol had this to say:
They were extremely accommodating to me with my collection and very friendly, helpful and fair with the prices. Testimonial written by Carol on this site.

Contact Us

Gary's Coins & Stamps
210 W Grand Ave Wisconsin Rapids, WI 54495
Phone: (715) 421-0822
Email: garyscswr@gmail.com

Where To Find Us

Payment Types Accepted

Personal Checks

Our Hours

Holiday Hours May Vary. Please Call For Details.

Monday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Tuesday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Wednesday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Thursday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Friday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Saturday: 10:00 AM - 2:00 PM

News

Step into the world of collectibles at Gary's Coins & Stamps! 🪙📚 Whether you're looking to buy, sell, or get appraisals, our collector shop has you covered. Visit us for an exceptional in-store shopping experience and uncover the stories behind every coin and stamp. 🔍✉️

FAQ

What does Gary’s Coins & Stamps specialize in?

Gary’s Coins & Stamps offers a wide range of collectible items, including rare coins, U.S. and foreign currency, postage stamps, antiques, jewelry, and other historical collectibles. Our inventory is carefully curated to appeal to both seasoned collectors and those just beginning their journey. We focus on authenticity, historical value, and quality so every piece tells a meaningful story.

How long have you been in business?

We were founded in 1979 and have proudly served collectors for more than 45 years. As a long‑standing local shop, we’ve built a reputation for honesty, expertise, and a deep respect for the history behind every item we handle.

Do you offer appraisals?

Yes. We provide professional appraisals for coins, currency, stamps, antiques, and full collections. Whether you need an appraisal for personal knowledge, estate planning, insurance purposes, or selling, our evaluations are thorough, accurate, and based on decades of experience in the collectibles market.

Do you buy collections or individual items?

Absolutely. We purchase single items, partial collections, and entire estates. Whether you have a handful of coins or a lifetime collection, we offer fair, transparent evaluations and competitive offers based on current market value.

What kinds of items do you buy?

We buy a wide variety of collectibles, including:

U.S. and foreign coins

Paper currency

Stamp collections

Gold and silver items

Jewelry

Antiques and historical memorabilia
If you’re unsure whether your item qualifies, bring it in — we’re always happy to take a look.

Do you sell collectible coins and stamps in-store?

Yes. Our shop features a rotating selection of rare coins, currency, stamps, and unique antiques. Inventory changes frequently, so collectors often stop in regularly to see what’s new.

Can you help new collectors get started?

Definitely. We love working with beginners and helping them understand grading, value, preservation, and how to build a meaningful collection. Whether you’re starting with a few coins or exploring stamps for the first time, we’re here to guide you.

Do you authenticate coins or stamps?

We provide expert opinions based on decades of experience and can help you understand authenticity indicators, grading standards, and market value. For high‑value items requiring formal certification, we can guide you through the process of submitting to major grading services.

Do you offer advice on preserving or storing collectibles?

Yes. We can recommend proper storage materials, handling techniques, and environmental considerations to help protect your collection from damage, fading, or deterioration.

Can I bring in items for a quick evaluation?

Absolutely. Walk‑ins are welcome, and we’re happy to provide a quick look at your items. For large collections or estate evaluations, calling ahead helps us set aside dedicated time.